Social Security is deep in deficit, and once its trust fund is depleted, under the law, it cannot pay more in benefits than it generates in revenue. In just six years, beneficiaries will face an abrupt 22% benefit cut – the equivalent of a roughly $500 cut in monthly benefits per beneficiary. That’s more than what the average retired household spends on groceries each month.
If policymakers try to paper over this cut with general revenue funding, it would add $190 trillion to the debt over the next 75 years – enough to set off a debt spiral – and end Social Security as we know it as a self-financed contributory program.
The problem is evident from a quick glance at the total size of the trust funds. With costs rising, it is easy to see how the reserves risk being depleted within a decade.
This month, the Clark Center’s US Economic Experts Panel weighed in to offer a series of potential fixes, all of which are relatively easy to administer in theory but each of which also is likely to provoke a political backlash.
Back in 1937, when payroll taxes to fund Social Security were first enacted, earnings over $3000 a year were excluded. In inflation-adjusted terms, that would be around $65,000 today. And yet, under the current arrangements, earnings over $184,500 – almost three times as much – are free from these charges.
Weighed by confidence, 96% of respondents agreed or strongly agreed that ‘removing the cap on earnings subject to Social Security payroll taxes, without increasing benefits for earnings above the current cap, would substantially improve the program’s long-term financial sustainability and make it more progressive’.
In other words, subjecting higher incomes to these payroll taxes would materially boost the fund’s income and help to put it on a much firmer footing.
On the other hand, while agreeing with the proposition, several respondents noted that this would be a large tax rise for many households and one that would likely have other economic impacts. As Joseph Altonji of Yale argued, ‘I agree with the statement, although labor supply responses by high earners to the higher marginal tax rate will reduce the gains and reduce general tax revenue. Expanding the tax to cover nonwage compensation is a better option’.
More than 90% of respondents, again weighted by confidence, agreed or strongly agreed that ‘automatically adjusting the Social Security full retirement age in line with increases in life expectancy would substantially improve the program’s long-term financial sustainability’.
Again, though, there were some important caveats. As Chicago Booth’s Erik Hurst noted, ‘Average life expectancy has plateaued during the last few decades. It is the life expectancy gains of the past that are causing the fiscal problems’.
That said, the CFRFB’s own calculator, as the Clark Center’s Anil Kashyap pointed out, shows that linking the retirement age to life expectancy improves the projected sustainability by 17%.
Another potential step would be to link future benefits to changes in prices rather than wages. The panel was asked whether ‘replacing wage indexation with price indexation in the calculation of initial Social Security retirement benefits would substantially improve the program’s long-term financial sustainability without undermining its social insurance function’?
Support for this was a little more guarded. More than half of respondents, once again weighted by confidence, supported the statement, but uncertainty – at 38% – was higher on this issue.
Daron Acemoglu of MIT argued that he was uncertain as ‘there is no guarantee that with AI-driven automation, wage increases will be faster than price increases in the future’. Larry Samuelson of Yale echoed that point by agreeing but noting that he was ‘assuming that wages increase faster than prices, which is plausible not assured’.
There are, as is clear, various ways open to policymakers to either increase Social Security’s income – through effectively raising taxes – or to trim its future costs by raising the age at which these benefits can be claimed or linking them to prices rather than wages (assuming that wages outpace prices over the medium to longer run). Of course all of these options involve, to one degree or another, creating a set of relative losers – those paying more taxes now or receiving lower payments in the future. Which option – if any – is eventually settled on will depend on the often hard-to-predict path of political economy, as on the advice of economists.
