US

The Invisible Hand

Question A:

Adam Smith’s metaphor of the invisible hand has been foundational to the development of modern economic theory.

Responses weighted by each expert's confidence

Question B:

Adam Smith’s metaphor of the invisible hand has been commonly misinterpreted as advocacy for pure laissez-faire capitalism.

Responses weighted by each expert's confidence

Question A Participant Responses

Participant University Vote Confidence Bio/Vote History
Acemoglu
Daron Acemoglu
MIT
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
Altonji
Joseph Altonji
Yale
Strongly Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Auerbach
Alan Auerbach
Berkeley
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Autor
David Autor
MIT
Agree
6
Bio/Vote History
It's a pretty compelling simile! (It's not a metaphor, as your high school English teacher dutifully taught you. I'm going to regret writing this parenthetical note.)
Banerjee
Abhijit Banerjee
MIT
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Bertrand
Marianne Bertrand
Chicago
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Brunnermeier
Markus Brunnermeier
Princeton
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Along with the division of labor
Chetty
Raj Chetty
Harvard Did Not Answer Bio/Vote History
Chevalier
Judith Chevalier
Yale
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Cutler
David Cutler
Harvard
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Deaton
Angus Deaton
Princeton
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Duffie
Darrell Duffie
Stanford
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Edlin
Aaron Edlin
Berkeley
Agree
6
Bio/Vote History
Eichengreen
Barry Eichengreen
Berkeley
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
Einav
Liran Einav
Stanford
Strongly Agree
1
Bio/Vote History
Fair
Ray Fair
Yale
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
Finkelstein
Amy Finkelstein
MIT Did Not Answer Bio/Vote History
Goldberg
Pinelopi Goldberg
Yale
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Greenstone
Michael Greenstone
University of Chicago
Agree
4
Bio/Vote History
Hall
Robert Hall
Stanford
Uncertain
1
Bio/Vote History
Hart
Oliver Hart
Harvard
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Holmström
Bengt Holmström
MIT
Strongly Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
A catalyst for theorizing about markets and price formation - absolutely
Hoxby
Caroline Hoxby
Stanford
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
The invisible hand is foundational to all notions of partial and general equilibrium in economics. It certainly drew me into economics and (I have no doubt) has drawn in many others as well. Any who truly understands economics implicitly relies on this concept.
Hoynes
Hilary Hoynes
Berkeley
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Judd
Kenneth Judd
Stanford
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Kaplan
Steven Kaplan
Chicago Booth
Agree
6
Bio/Vote History
Kashyap
Anil Kashyap
Chicago Booth
Strongly Agree
9
Bio/Vote History
Klenow
Pete Klenow
Stanford
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Levin
Jonathan Levin
Stanford
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Maskin
Eric Maskin
Harvard
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
The first welfare theorem---a fundamental finding in economic theory---is essentially a formalization of the invisible hand.
Nordhaus
William Nordhaus
Yale
Agree
9
Bio/Vote History
A wonderful metaphor and inspirational for economist-poets. Only proven almost two centuries later with appropriate reservations.
Obstfeld
Maurice Obstfeld
Berkeley
Strongly Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Saez
Emmanuel Saez
Berkeley
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Samuelson
Larry Samuelson
Yale
Strongly Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Variations on the concept of the invisible hand, culminating in the two fundamental welfare theorems, play a central role in our understanding of the possibilities and limitations of decentralized resource allocation.
Scheinkman
José Scheinkman
Columbia University
Strongly Agree
9
Bio/Vote History
Schmalensee
Richard Schmalensee
MIT
Strongly Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Shapiro
Carl Shapiro
Berkeley
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Shimer
Robert Shimer
University of Chicago
Strongly Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Stock
James Stock
Harvard Did Not Answer Bio/Vote History
Thaler
Richard Thaler
Chicago Booth
Strongly Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
Udry
Christopher Udry
Northwestern
Disagree
6
Bio/Vote History
The metaphor is important as it is used now, but it's not how Smith actually used the phrase.

Question B Participant Responses

Participant University Vote Confidence Bio/Vote History
Acemoglu
Daron Acemoglu
MIT
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
The invisible hand and its formalization, first welfare theorem, are beautiful and thought-provoking. But their insights should not be applied when their conditions are not met. In real world, monopoly, power, politics and other market failures are pervasive and cannot be ignored
Altonji
Joseph Altonji
Yale
Strongly Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Auerbach
Alan Auerbach
Berkeley
Uncertain
5
Bio/Vote History
Autor
David Autor
MIT
Agree
6
Bio/Vote History
Reading Smith is a Rorschach test. And although Rorschach tests have no wrong answers, many have failed when it comes to Smith
Banerjee
Abhijit Banerjee
MIT
Agree
6
Bio/Vote History
Bertrand
Marianne Bertrand
Chicago
Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Brunnermeier
Markus Brunnermeier
Princeton
Agree
6
Bio/Vote History
See Viner’s JPE (1926) article. Adam Smith also captured many “behavioral” aspects.
Chetty
Raj Chetty
Harvard Did Not Answer Bio/Vote History
Chevalier
Judith Chevalier
Yale
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Cutler
David Cutler
Harvard
Agree
6
Bio/Vote History
Deaton
Angus Deaton
Princeton
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Duffie
Darrell Duffie
Stanford
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Edlin
Aaron Edlin
Berkeley
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Eichengreen
Barry Eichengreen
Berkeley
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
I would prefer the wording "Adam Smith's writings have been wrongly interpreted as advocacy for pure laissez-faire capitalism."
Einav
Liran Einav
Stanford
Uncertain
1
Bio/Vote History
Fair
Ray Fair
Yale
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
Finkelstein
Amy Finkelstein
MIT Did Not Answer Bio/Vote History
Goldberg
Pinelopi Goldberg
Yale
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Greenstone
Michael Greenstone
University of Chicago
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Hall
Robert Hall
Stanford
Uncertain
1
Bio/Vote History
Hart
Oliver Hart
Harvard
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Holmström
Bengt Holmström
MIT
Agree
6
Bio/Vote History
Hoxby
Caroline Hoxby
Stanford
Strongly Agree
10
Bio/Vote History
Only ignorant, unread, & intellectually shallow people believe that the invisible hand is equal to Laissez Faire. The concepts are entirely different/orthogonal. Conflating one concept with the other displays an unforgiveable unwillingness or gross incapacity to learn economics.
Hoynes
Hilary Hoynes
Berkeley
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Judd
Kenneth Judd
Stanford
Agree
9
Bio/Vote History
Kaplan
Steven Kaplan
Chicago Booth
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
Kashyap
Anil Kashyap
Chicago Booth
Agree
3
Bio/Vote History
sometimes misinterpreted for sure, lots of what he wrote has been forgotten and the caricature has taken hold.
Klenow
Pete Klenow
Stanford
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
Levin
Jonathan Levin
Stanford
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Maskin
Eric Maskin
Harvard
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Once we understand what assumptions need to hold for the first welfare theorem to go through, we see that there are many circumstances (e.g., monopoly power or externalities) where a laissez-faire approach is not warranted.
Nordhaus
William Nordhaus
Yale
Uncertain
9
Bio/Vote History
Didn't need this metaphor to defend social Darwinism, monopolies, cartels, and ruinous degradations of the economy and polity.
Obstfeld
Maurice Obstfeld
Berkeley
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Saez
Emmanuel Saez
Berkeley
Agree
5
Bio/Vote History
Samuelson
Larry Samuelson
Yale
Strongly Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Too often, the conclusions of the welfare theorems are emphasized and the required conditions ignored.
Scheinkman
José Scheinkman
Columbia University
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Schmalensee
Richard Schmalensee
MIT
Uncertain
4
Bio/Vote History
Sometimes, yes, but commonly seems too strong.
Shapiro
Carl Shapiro
Berkeley
Agree
8
Bio/Vote History
Shimer
Robert Shimer
University of Chicago
Uncertain
5
Bio/Vote History
Adam Smith recognized some limits to laissez-faire capitalism, notably in his discussion of collusion; however, he argued that the government cannot prevent collusion. It can only facilitate it through bad policies.
Stock
James Stock
Harvard Did Not Answer Bio/Vote History
Thaler
Richard Thaler
Chicago Booth
Uncertain
1
Bio/Vote History
Not sure how to answer this. No data.
Udry
Christopher Udry
Northwestern
Agree
7
Bio/Vote History
Smith had much to say about the dangers of traders conspiring to manipulate markets.